-->

Electric Charges And Fields

Question
CBSEENPH12037289

Two negative charges of unit magnitude and a positive charge q are placed along a straight line. At what position and for what value of q will the system be in equilibrium? Check whether it is a stable or neutral equilibrium. 


Solution
Let the charge q be at distances r1and r2 from the two charges P and Q respectively, as shown in the figure below:


For equilibrium of q, the forces on it exerted by P and Q must be co-linear, equal and opposite.

Force on q by P 

       FqP = q4πε0 r12 towards p

Force on q by Q 

      FqQ = q4πε0r22 towards Q

               FqP = FqQ    or   qr12 = qr22
                     r1 =r2 = r

Hence charge q should be equidistant from P and Q.


For the system to be in equilibrium, the charges P and Q must also be in equilibrium.
Now,

Fpq = force on P by q = q4πε0r2 (towards q)FPQ = force on Q by P =14πε0(2r)2(away from P and away from q)

Since F
pq and FPQ are oppositely directed along the same line, we have, for equilibrium,
           
               q4πε0r2 = 14πε0(4r2)
or                   q = 14
Similarly for the equilibrium of Q, we would get
q = 14. 
Thus q = 14 in magnitude of either charge P or Q.

Stability: A slight displacement of q towards P increases the magnitude of F
qP and decreases the magnitude of FqQ. Consequently, the displacement of q is increased. Thus the three charges are no longer in equilibrium. Hence the original equilibrium is unstable for displacement along the axis on which the charges are located. For a displacement of q along a direction normal to the line PQ, the resultant of the two forces of attraction Fqp and FqQ will bring the charge q back to its original position. Thus the equilibrium is stable for displacement in the vertical direction.