-->

Framing The Constitution

Question
CBSEENHS12028065

The problem of separate electorates was an intricate problem that confronted the Constituent Assembly. Discuss the debate help in the Assembly over this issue.

Solution

Arguments in favour of Separate Electorates

(i) It is a political framework in which minorities can live in harmony with people who are in majority.

(ii) It is an arrangement which can minimise differences between different communities.

(iii) It can provide good representaion to the minorities in the political system of the country.

(iv) It enables other to hear voice of the minority and take into account its views and opinions.

(v) Only the minority people can choose their true representative.

Arguments against Separate Electorates

(i) It was a measure deliberately introduced by the foreign rulers to divide the people.

(ii) It can lead to riots, violence and civil war.

(iii) It is a poison in any political system.

(iv) It divides the nation and causes bloodshed as one community turns against the other.

(v) It is a mischief left behind by the British.

(vi) It is harmful not only to the nation but also to the minorities. It is rather suicidal to the minorities.

(vii) It is self-destructive as it isolates the minorities from the majority.

(viii) It divides loyalty of the citizens towards their nation.