-->

Aldehydes, Ketones And Carboxylic Acids

Question
CBSEENCH12010220

Give simple tests to distinguish between the following pairs of compounds

 (i) Pentan-2-one and Pentan-3-one

 (ii) Benzaldehyde and Acetophenone

 (iii) Phenol and Benzoic acid

Solution

i) Pentan-2-one and pentan-3-one can be distinguished by iodoform test.
Pentan-2-one is a methyl ketone. Thus, it responds to this test. But pentan-3-one not being a methyl ketone does not respond to this test.

ii) Benzaldehyde (C6H5CHO) and acetophenone (C6H5COCH3) can be distinguished by iodoform test. Acetophenone, being a methyl ketone on treatment with I2/NaOH undergoes iodoform reaction to give a yellow ppt. of iodoform. On the other hand, Benzaldehyde does not give this test.

iii) Phenol and benzoic acid can be distinguished by ferric chloride test.

Ferric chloride test:

Phenol reacts with neutral FeCl3 to form ferric phenoxide complex giving violet coloration.

 6C6H5OH + FeCl3 ---> [Fe (OC6H5)6]3-+3H++3Cl-

Phenol                         iron-phenol complex

                                      (Violet color)

But benzoic acid reacts with neutral FeCl3 to give a buff-coloured precipitate of ferric benzoate.
stack 3 straight C subscript 6 straight H subscript 5 COOH space plus FeCl subscript 3 space with Benzoic below rightwards arrow space stack left parenthesis straight C subscript 6 straight H subscript 5 COO right parenthesis subscript 3 Fe space with Ferric space benzoate below plus 3 HCl