-->

Hydrocarbons

Question
CBSEENCH11007862

Discuss the structure of benzene with special reference to Kekule structure. 

Solution

The molecular formula of benzene is C6Hindicating a high degree of unsaturation. As a result, benzene is expected to be highly reactive compound like alkenes or alkynes. Therefore benzene should:
(i)  decolourise aqueous potassium permanganate. 
(ii) add water in the presence of acids.
(iii) decolourise bromine water.
But actually, benzene does not undergo such reactions. This implies that benzene is different from alkenes and alkynes. Moreover, being extraordinarily stable, it behaves more like alkanes than an alkene or alkynes. It prefers to undergo substitution reactions rather than addition.
Since benzene on catalytic hydrogenation forms cyclohexane (a ring compound), this suggests that the carbon skeleton of benzene should be a six-membered cyclic structure.

stack straight C subscript 6 straight H subscript 6 with Benzen below space plus space 3 straight H subscript 2 space space rightwards arrow with Ni. space 423 space straight K on top

Kekule’s structure of benzene: Kekule proposed that benzene has a ring structure in which

the six carbon atoms are arranged in the form of a regular hexagon and one hydrogen each is bonded to each carbon atom. Since carbon is tetravalent, he proposed that alternate single and double bonds are present between carbon atoms.

Objections to Kekule’s structure:
(i) Kekule’s structure allows the existence of two isomeric orthos-substituted dibromo benzene (I and NY).

But actually there is only one o-dibromo- benzene known. To overcome this objection, he himself proposed that the double and single bonds in benzene are not rigidly fixed ; the double bonds rapidly shift back and forth and there exists a dynamic equilibrium in between isomers a and b and they can never be isolated.

(ii) Kekule’s structure does not explain the extra ordinary stable nature of benzene molecule and its lack of reactivity towards addition reactions, resistance towards oxidation etc.
(iii) Equivalence of all the carbon-carbon bond lengths in benzene.