Organic Chemistry – Some Basic Principles and Techniques

Question
CBSEENCH11007577

Explain hyperconjugation effect or no-bond resonance.

Solution

This effect is also called anchimeric effect or Balker Nathan effect. 
This effect is explained on the basis of:
(i) molecular orbital concept and
(ii) resonance effect.
(iii) Explanation of the molecular orbital concept. Hyperconjugation is the derealization of the electrons brought about by the sideway overlapping of the p-orbitals of the double bond and σ; orbital of the C – H bond of the alkyl group pz electrons of the double bond and (sp3 – s) σ;-orbital of C – H bond. For example, let us consider the delocalisation of electrons in the alkene   where represents an alkyl group. The delocalisation may be shown as:
 
Thus electron pair forming C – H bond of the straight alpha-carbon not only binds these atoms (C and H) together but also binds the two carbon atoms of the double bond to some extent. Similarly, the electron pair forming the straight pi;-bond not only binds these doubly bonded carbon atoms together but also binds the carbon and hydrogen atoms to some extent. In other words, delocalisation helps in bonding together all the four atoms to some extent i.e. there are four electrons delocalised over four nuclei (C1 C2, C3 and H).
(ii) Explanation of resonance effect. According to this concept, if an alkyl group carrying at least one hydrogen is attached to an unsaturated carbon atom, it releases the electrons of C–H bond towards the multiple bonds. For example, propylene can be considered to be resonance hybrid of the following four structures:

Structures I, II and III are hyperconjugation structures. Since there is no bond between carbon and hydrogen atom in these structures, hyperconjugation is also called no-bond resonance. Therefore, more the number of such straight alpha-hydrogen atoms, more are the number of hyperconjugation structures and hence greater is the inductive effect. The number of hydrogen atoms is three with the methyl group, two with the ethyl group, one with the isopropyl group and none with the tertbutyl group. Thus, the order of hyperconjugation effect decreases in the order:
CH3 – > CH3CH2 – > (CH3)2CH – > (CH3)3C –

Sponsor Area

Question
CBSEENCH11007578

Explain why alkyl groups act as electron donors when attached to a straight pi semicolon minus system.

Solution

Alkyl group has no lone pair of electrons but it acts as an electron donor when attached to a straight pi semicolon- electron system because of hyperconjugation. Carbon is slightly more electronegative than hydrogen. Thus, the carbon atom in an alkyl group has higher electron density around it as compared with an H atom. As a result, alkyl group are able to donate electrons inductively when attached to a pi system. Let us illustrate this by taking an example of propylene. The various resonating structures are as follows:


Sponsor Area

Question
CBSEENCH11007579

What are carbocations? Discuss the relative stabilities of primary, secondary and tertiary carbocations.

Solution

A group of atoms having positively charged carbon atom, which has six electrons in the valence shell is called carbocation. For example straight C with plus on top straight H subscript 3 space and space CH subscript 3 space minus space straight C with plus on top straight H subscript 2 are two simple carbocations known as methyl cation and ethyl cations respectively? Carbocations are very short-lived and highly reactive species. Among primary  (1°), secondary (2°) and tertiary (3°) carbocations, 3° is most stable.

The above stability order can be explained by:
(i) Inductive effect
(ii) Hyperconjugation effet.

(i) Inductive effect: Alkyl groups have +I effect. In the carbocation, the alkyl group releases electrons to the positive carbon and thus reduces its charge and in turn itself becomes somewhat positive. Greater the dispersal of charge, greater will be the stability of carbocation. Thus, tertiary carbocations with three alkyl groups are more stable than secondary (with two alkyl groups) which in turn is more stable than primary (with one alkyl group). The methyl carbonium ion is least stable as it has no alkyl group.
(ii) Hyperconjugative effect. Greater the hyper conjugative structures, greater will be the stability of the ion.


Since tertiary butyl carbocation has maximum (10) number of canonical forms, so it is most stable. 
The order of stability is 3 degree thin space greater than 2 degree space greater than space 1 degree greater than straight C with plus on top straight H subscript 3

Question
CBSEENCH11007580

Give two methods for the generation of carbocation. Describe its structure. 

Solution

(i) Direct ionisation: The carbon-halogen bond (C-X) in many organic halides generates carbocations in the presence of a highly polar medium.

(ii) Protonation of alkene:

The structure of carbocation: The positively charged carbon of the carbocation is sp2 state of hybridisation. The three sp2 hybridised orbitals which lie in the same plane are involved in the formation of three bonds with other atoms. The unhybridised p-orbital remains vacant. Thus, the carbocation has a flat structure. 

The bond angle around the positively charged carbon is nearly 120° each.